Wisconsin Old Fashioned Recipe

Treat Yourself to a Wisconsin Old Fashioned

You may have had an Old Fashioned cocktail in other parts of the world, but in Wisconsin it is a kinder and gentler adult beverage. Made popular in taverns and supper clubs throughout the state, the Old Fashioned is a staple.

You really should try it as a slush… it is a party maker.

Miss Mary’s proudly launched our Wisconsin Old Fashioned Mix in 2020 to pay homage to our home state (and because we ALL needed a cocktail that year).

Close up of Wisconsin Old Fashioneds

What is a Wisconsin Old Fashioned?

If you think Wisconsin is all dairy farms and small towns, you don’t know the (literally) rich history of the vacationing glitterati in places like Lake Geneva and the famously charming Door County. 

That doesn't make the Wisconsin Old Fashioned a fancy-folk thing... you can find this delicious brandy-based cocktail in just about any tavern, dive bar, or outdoor festival throughout the Dairy State.

Wisconsin’s approach to the Old Fashioned is distinctive, winning it a cult-following. Ask any alumnus from the world-famous University of Wisconsin system and they'll tell you - once you've had a Wisconsin Old Fashioned, you'll always have a soft spot for them.

Unlike the rest of the world, Wisconsin makes the Old Fashioned with brandy. And while that may sound like your grandma's liquor of choice, don't knock it until you've tried it. It is especially delicious served fireside during a snow storm. 

Our favorite is having a Wisconsin Old Fashioned at the local Supper Club during Friday Fish Fry (two more Wisconsin things that you're going to want to try out asap). The way we hear it, upscale “Supper Clubs” are making quite a comeback.

Why not serve Miss Mary’s Old Fashioned Mix at your next dinner party?

Miss Mary's Old Fashioned Mix and bottle of Korbel Brandy

How to Order a Wisconsin Old Fashioned

A traditional Old Fashioned includes bourbon, sugar, and bitters. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned, however, has a few more ingredients. For example, you could order your Wisconsin Old Fashioned:

  • Sweet – with a floater (aka ‘wash’) of Sprite or 7up,
  • Sour – with a grapefruit soda like Squirt or 50/50 (actual Sour Mix works too), or
  • Pressed – with a combo of soda + seltzer (less sugar, more liquor flavor).

Our goal when we created Miss Mary's Tavern-style Old Fashioned Mix was to deliver the flavors of the famous cocktail with less sugar and fewer complicated steps. 

We think you should spend more time sipping your cocktail than mixing it.

Wisconsin Old Fashioned with traditional garnish of cherry and orange peel

How to Make a Wisconsin Old Fashioned

Combine 3 parts Brandy (we suppose you could make it with Bourbon if you're a trouble maker from Chicago*) with 1 part Miss Mary’s Old Fashioned in a rocks glass over ice. THAT'S IT.

We made it easy so you can enjoy the PERFECT cocktail any time.
Like we said, cocktails are meant to be enjoyed, not fussed over.

You can garnish with designer cherries or your basic Maraschino, and finish with a peel or wheel of orange for a fun pop of color or snacks for later. You can even glam it up with a Cara or Blood Orange if you’re feeling #extra.

If you haven’t tried a Wisconsin Old Fashioned in a while, let our version be what brings you back to your roots (or to ours).


    Make This Recipe 👇

     

    star

    ← Older Post Newer Post →

    Leave a comment

    Low-Sugar Living

    RSS
    words "eat less sugar" written into spilled sugar on butcher block
    #lowsugarliving artificial sweeteners coffee syrups how to lemonade lite margarita low sugar living low-sugar no artificial sweeteners popular sucralose sugar-free sugarfree

    Low-Sugar Lifestyle Guide: Ditch Sugar, Not The Fun

    Low-sugar living means cutting back on added sugar, not giving up the drinks and treats you love. Here are five everyday places to swap sugar...

    Read more
    Lemon Vanilla Spritz cocktail with Madagascar Vanilla syrup bottle on beige background
    #lowsugarrecipe alcoholic drink apperitif cocktail recipe cocktail-recipes low sugar cocktail low sugar recipe madagascar vanilla recipe Sinless Cocktail skinny cocktail summer cocktail summer recipe vanilla vodka cocktail

    Lemon Vanilla Spritz Recipe

    Summertime cocktails are in a special class by themselves. The challenge for any of us on a low-sugar journey is to find a version of...

    Read more
    Toasted Marshmallow Sinless Syrup with yogurt and pecans on neutral background
    #lowsugarrecipe all-recipes breakfast dairy featured healthy choice keto keto recipe keto-friendly low sugar recipe low-carb low-sugar no artificial sweeteners protein s'mores sinless syrup sinless syrups snack toasted marshmallow

    Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bowl

    What's not to love about the flavors of s'mores meets "turtle" served up with just 5g of sugar? Get ready for a creamy, crunchy, protein-packed...

    Read more
    Low Sugar Cocktail

    Wisconsin Old Fashioned Recipe

    Don't sleep on Wisconsin. Say what you will about the weather, but those folks know how to have a good time. In fact, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned has to be the greatest thing to come out of Wisconsin since cheese. No, really. 

    This recipe uses Miss Mary's low sugar Wisconsin Tavern-Style Old Fashioned cocktail mix for the most convenient way to enjoy this cocktail at home.

    No ratings yet

    Servings

    1

    Prep Time

    2 minutes

    Calories

    230

    Author:

    Miss Mary’s Mix

    Ingredients

    • 1 oz. Miss Mary’s Old Fashioned Mix
    • 3 oz. Brandy
    • Optional Garnish: Slice of Orange, Cherry

    Directions

    1. Combine ingredients in a Lowball glass with ice.
    2. Add garnish & enjoy.

    Recipe Note

    This unfussy recipe is perfect for parties because absolutely anyone can mix two ingredients together.

    (It also comes in handy on days when you just need something to be easy for a change. You know the ones.)

    For a luxe touch, drop in a Luxardo Cherry or two. Trust us… they’re worth it.